| Date | Challenger | Runs (by inning) | Presider | Runs (by inning) | Venue | Notes | Performance |
| 19JUN25 | Spaghettiland Marshmallows | 2 (2-0) |
Kelm Caspers | 6 (6-0) |
Radical Park | 1st Summer Challenge: 45 minute rain delay. Scottie Smith (Caspers) started the scoring with a 2 run homer against Chris Smith (Marshmallows). | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Chris Smith 3. Edwin Hammerbeck |
| 19JUN25 | New Jonesland Fancy Dandies | 5 (2-3) |
Telm Kaisers | 0 (0-0) |
Radical Park | 1st Summer Challenge: Scottie Smith (New Jonesland) hit a homerun on the 1st pitch against Chris Smith (Telm Kaisers). Scottie pitched a 1 hitter. | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Bruno Mondragon 3. Chris Smith 4. Yanni Mondragon |
| 02MAY25 | King's Turtle Wings | 3 (0-3-0) |
Chelm Chamoyadas | 5 (2-0-3) |
Radical Park | 1 out walk off. Yanni Mondragon's (Turtle Wings) debut match. Gets his first hit and thrown strikeout. Bruno Mondragon (Turtle Wings) gets his first homerun. | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Bruno Mondragon 3. Yanni Mondragon |
| 26APR25 | Indigenous Chelm | 7 (7) |
Kelm Cool Guys | 0 (0) |
Radical Park | 1st Spring Challenge: Chelm dominated both offense and defense. After Chelm fans were rooting against the Cool Guys, Scottie Smith (Cool Guys) threw the ball at the audience when on the mound. The ball hit a spectator in the stomach at high speed which caused fans to rush the field. | 1. Greg Smith 2. Chris Smith 3. Scottie Smith |
| 09MAR25 | Verdenia Turtle Wings | 4 (0-2-2) |
Kelm Cool Guys | 5 (4-1-X) |
Radical Park | - | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Bruno Mondragon |
| 30JAN25 | Verdenia Turtle Wings | 8 (6-1-0-0-1) |
Kelm Cool Guys | 12 (5-0-3-0-4) |
Radical Park | First game ever played in January as temperatures reach over 50F. Exciting game that ended in 1 out walk off. | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Bruno Mondragon |
| 20OCT24 | Avengerdonia Turtle Wings | 3 (1-1-1) | Kelm Cool Guys | 1 (0-0-1) | Chelm | Greg Smith (Turtle Wings) throws several strikeouts and hits 2 homeruns in his first game since the 1990s. Nancy Weckerly's debut match. | 1. Greg Smith 2. Scottie Smith 3. Chris Smith 4. Bruno Mondragon 5. Edwin Hammerbeck 6. Nancy Weckerly |
| 17OCT24 | Avengerdonia Turtle Wings | 1 (1-0-0) | Kelm Cool Guys | 3 (3-0-X) | Chelm | - | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Bruno Mondragon |
| 28SEP24 | Avengerdonia Turtle Wings | 0 | Kelm Cool Guys | 4 | Chelm | 2.5 innings. Edwin Hammerbeck's (Turtle Wings) debut match (gets first carrer hit and thrown strikeout). Bruno Mondragon (Turtle Wings) threw a strike so fast that it caused Scottie Smith's (Cool Guys) gum to fall out while swinging. | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Bruno Mondragon 3. Edwin Hammerbeck |
| 25SEP24 | Avengerdonia Turtle Wings | 1 | Kelm Cool Guys | 3 | Tree Opolis | 2.5 innings. Dan Ryker (Turtle Wings) lost shoe during gameplay, living up to the team's second nickname the Shoeless Wonders. | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Dan Ryker 3. Bruno Mondragon |
| 25SEP24 | Avengerdonia Turtle Wings | 3 | Kelm Cool Guys | 4 | Tree Opolis | 2.5 innings. Dan Ryker's debut match. | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Dan Ryker 3. Bruno Mondragon |
| 04OCT23 | Avengerdonia Turtle Wings | 0 | Kelm Cool Guys | 13 | Tree Opolis | 2.5 innings. Bruno Mondragon's debut match. | 1. Scottie Smith 2. Bruno Mondragon |